Welcome to

Sensible Shoe

Your premier family footwear store in Rutland, Vermont

Shop MenShop Women

Experience the difference with our Sit and Fit service

At Sensible Shoe, we pride ourselves on being more than just a footwear store. Located in the heart of Rutland, Vermont, we offer a unique sit-and-fit service where our knowledgeable sales associates personally measure your feet and help you find the perfect footwear. Whether you’re looking for comfort, style, or a specific fit, we are here to ensure you leave with exactly what you need.

  • Award-Winning Service

    Voted Best Local Shoe Store by the Rutland Herald’s Readers’ Choice Awards multiple years running

  • Personalized Service

    Sit and fit experience with expert associates

  • Outstanding Customer Service

    Recipient of the Gold Medal Service Award for Outstanding Customer Service by Footwear Insights Magazine

  • Quality Brands

    A curated selection of the best footwear brands

  • Family-Owned and Operated

    Four generations of footwear expertise

  • Local Commitment

    Proudly serving the greater Rutland area and Central Vermont

New Arrivals

Shop by Category

  • Men's Footwear

    Explore our collection of men’s shoes, boots, and sandals

  • Women's Footwear

    Discover stylish and comfortable shoes, boots, and sandals for every occasion

  • Kid's Footwear

    Find the perfect fit for your little ones, from school shoes to playtime boots

  • Socks

    Browse our variety of high-quality socks for the entire family

Popular Brands

View All Brands
View All Brands

Featured Products

AetrexAltra RunningAriat
  • Women's Maui

    Women's Maui

    Sold out

    Women's Maui

    Aetrex
    $59.95 USD
    $59.95 USD $59.95 USD
    Sold out
  • Women's Bondi

    Women's Bondi

    Women's Bondi

    Aetrex
    $64.95 USD
    $64.95 USD $64.95 USD
  • Women's Bali

    Women's Bali

    Sold out

    Women's Bali

    Aetrex
    $59.95 USD
    $59.95 USD $59.95 USD
    Sold out
  • Men's Maui

    Men's Maui

    Sold out

    Men's Maui

    Aetrex
    $59.95 USD
    $59.95 USD $59.95 USD
    Sold out
  • Men's Bondi

    Men's Bondi

    Men's Bondi

    Aetrex
    $64.95 USD
    $64.95 USD $64.95 USD
  • Men's Bali

    Men's Bali

    Men's Bali

    Aetrex
    $59.95 USD
    $59.95 USD $59.95 USD

What Our Customers Are Saying

Write A Review

  • Micki B.

    I would like to recognize how wonderful this shoe store is! I wasn't able too wear a certain brand of sneakers. When I went in to seek more help in selecting a right fit for myself,  I was so happy that Joben was very patient and took the time to find the perfect fit for me. I know where I will go to get new shoes!

  • Charles F.

    Great local shoe store, with the most friendly, knowledgeable, and helpful staff.  And, they periodically offer great sales — we have sought shoes and socks here for several years and are happy to be on their email list.

  • Michael M.

    Pair text with an image to focus on your chosen product, collection, or blog post. Add details on availability, style, or even provide a review.

  • Brent L.

    Was coming through town as an AT hiker. Had no way of getting to the store to replace my 700-mile Altras. Called and they had the exact size and even color I wanted. The owner himself drove them to me, in town, after closing. Really cool guy and saved me a bunch of hassle.

  • Kyle T.

    Was coming through town as an AT hiker. Had no way of getting to the store to replace my 700-mile Altras. Called and they had the exact size and even color I wanted. The owner himself drove them to me, in town, after closing. Really cool guy and saved me a bunch of hassle.

  • Cate M.

    Was coming through town as an AT hiker. Had no way of getting to the store to replace my 700-mile Altras. Called and they had the exact size and even color I wanted. The owner himself drove them to me, in town, after closing. Really cool guy and saved me a bunch of hassle.